How To Choose a Career or College Major:
A Step-by-Step Guide
Tom G. Stevens PhD
STEP 1: GET READY
STEP 2: SELF-EXPLORATION--What
Do You Want?
STEP 3: CAREER EXPLORATION--Exploring The
World of Work
STEP 4: MAKE A DECISION--Step-by-Step
STEP 5:CAREER PREPARATION PLANNING
STEPS 6 & 7: ACTION
AND GATHERING FEEDBACK:
SUMMARY:
Also, Go to Dr. Stevens
Free online Success
and Happiness Attributes Questionnaire (SHAQ) for testing your academic
major interests, academic success factors, and many other career success related
scales.
Overview:
- Are you undecided about your major or Career?
- Would you like to find a career that best fits your interests
and abilities?
- You can learn a career planning process to help you make
career decisions throughout life.
- You can use this decision-making model to make many types
of important decisions.
- Avoiding a career decision or making a poor choice can be
very costly.
- The time you spend planning now can help add to your happiness
throughout your life.
Return to
INDEX
WHAT DECISION ARE YOU MAKING?
You may be thinking that you need to take some tests or think
hard until you find the ideal career for you. Actually, that is not how most people
make career decisions. Career decisions tend to be made in stages. At each stage
you learn a little more about what you want. Therefore, if you are a freshman or
sophomore and have not chosen a major or career, you are not alone. Eighty per cent
of college students change majors at least once.
CAREER DECISION LADDER
Following are examples of a typical progression of career decisions
people make. Which decision are you currently concerned about? You might think of
this progression of decisions as a career decision ladder.
- Whether or not to go to college.
- Which college to go to.
- Which general area to go into. Examples of general directions
include "Business," "Sales," "Scientific," "Teaching," "People-oriented," "Artistic,"
"A Medically-related field," "Sports-related," "Entertainment," or "Writing."
- Narrow down to 2 or 3 majors--taking courses in each and
exploring each in other ways. (Perhaps exploring the one with the most requirements
first.)
- Decide upon one major. (If the decision is very hard, you
might pick the one which seems to have access to more career directions
and closes fewest doors.)
- Decide which more specific occupation you want. (You might
decide this before you decide upon your major. On the other hand some people
never consciously decide which occupation they want.)
- Decide which specific job you want (during a job search).
- After you have worked in that job for awhile, decide if
you want to continue your same job or career or if you want to make a change.
- What future positions (such as promotions into management
positions) might you want?
Return to INDEX
WHICH TYPE OF DECISION ARE YOU MAKING?
As you may have noticed, making career decisions is actually
a life-long process. Since your career decisions can have about as much or more
effect on your overall satisfaction with life as any decision you ever make, spending
time making them effectively may be one of the best investments of your time you
ever make.
EXPERIENCES OF STUDENTS WHO DIDN'T MAKE A DECISION
What can happen if you don't make an effective decision? Following
are some actual situations of students I have talked with.
* Quote from a student, "When I was 18 I thought that someday
I would just know what I wanted to be, but now I am 30 and still don't know."
* Senior with about 120 units in various fields, "Now I've decided
that I really want to major in business, but it's going to take me almost three
years more to get my degree."
* Quote from former student who had been working for four years
in the field he majored in, "I knew when I was in college that I didn't like my
courses in this field very well, but I just kept going so I could graduate. Now
I am so unhappy in this that I am ready to come back to college and start over again
in something else. I wish I had really thought about what I wanted to do."
* Research has shown that students who are more clear about their
career goals tend to be more successful in college and make better grades. Do you
think this can't happen to you? It probably won't if you will take an active role
and EXPLORE, EXPLORE, EXPLORE YOURSELF and the WORLD OF WORK. Use this little guide
as a way of getting started and guiding your process.
Return to INDEX
WHERE TO GET HELP
CAREER COUNSELING
- You can receive Individual counseling and testing to help
you decide upon a major or career.
UNIVERSITY COURSES
- Try taking a course designed to help you learn more about
careers and plan your career.
CAREER INFORMATION CENTERS
- Start with books such as the Occupational Outlook Handbook
and Dictionary of Occupational Titles.. Look at literature from private
companies. Look into the computer program called SIGI. Look at videotapes that
have interviews with people who have knowledge of careers you are interested
in.
INFORMATION ABOUT MAJORS
- Go to the specific academic department you are interested
in and speak to a faculty advisor.
INTERVIEWS WITH PERSONS IN THE OCCUPATION
- Interviewing with persons in the occupation is probably
the best way that you can get information about the career. This will be discussed
in more depth below.
JOB SEARCH HELP
- You may want help in preparing and conducting a job search
or want a chance to participate in on-campus interviews for graduating seniors.
The classic book in this area is Bolles', What Color is Your Parachute?
Go to your COUNSELING CENTER or CAREER DEVELOPMENT CENTER.
WORK EXPERIENCE
- You may be able to get a great deal of information about
a career (plus some important experience to add to your resume) through work
experience. Work experience can be arranged which is paid, volunteer, or for
which you receive course credit.
TIP: Try your COOPERATIVE EDUCATION CENTER.
Return to INDEX
THE STEPS TO MAKING A CAREER DECISION
The process of making any career decisions is very similar.
* If you learn this career decision process,
it can help you with every career decision throughout your life.
This problem-solving model can also be used to help you make other
important life decisions--such as choice of a partner or buying a house or a car.
* Research has supported the conclusion that persons who were
more systematic in choosing their careers tend to be happier and more successful
in their careers.
You can use the following section as a guide to the steps of
making a career decision. You may not use all of the steps exactly as described
below; however, this section may help guide you through the process. The steps to
making a career decision include the following.
* STEP 1: GET READY
* STEP 2: SELF-EXPLORATION--Gather
information about yourself
* STEP 3: CAREER EXPLORATION--Gather
Information about the world of work and generate alternative career options
* STEP 4: MAKING A DECISION--NARROW
THE ALTERNATIVES
* STEP 5: PLANNING--MAKE A CAREER PREPARATION
PLAN
* STEPS 6&7: ACTION
AND FEEDBACK--TRY OUT YOUR CHOICES
Return to INDEX
Now we will take one step at a time for you to examine in more
detail. Do the suggested activities at each step as you are ready for them. You
may want to also seek help from your Counseling Center or Career Development Center
or attend Career Decision Workshops at either center.
STEP 1: GET READY
ASSIGN TIME TO EXPLORE AND DECIDE
Many students spend very little time on one the most important
decisions in their lives. Spending the equivalent of a 3-unit course to decide which
courses you will take for the other 121 or more units seems only reasonable.
WHICH DECISION ARE YOU MAKING?
Look at the examples above and try to clarify what you
need to decide and when need to make the decision. WHAT ARE YOUR INITIAL ALTERNATIVES
Make a list of the majors or occupations which you are currently considering. At
this point make it as large as is reasonable. Use general statements if necessary.
Return to INDEX
STEP 2:
SELF-EXPLORATION--
Gather information
about yourself
WHAT IS YOUR OVERALL GOAL THAT YOU WANT FROM YOUR CAREER (or
your life)?
What do you want most out of a job or career? I hear many answers
from people such as money, security, job satisfaction, or helping other people.
However, I suggest that most people would really rather have a happy life and help
contribute to the happiness of others in some way. In other words if you had a conflict
between being a rich, unhappy person and a non-rich, happy person--which would you
choose? That is a way to tell which of your values or selection criteria are the
most important to you. Understanding more clearly what you want out of a career
increases your chance at getting it.
If overall goals in your life are to be a happy person and
to contribute to others, then the next step is figuring out what it is that
you need to make you happy and productive. Most of us assume that a higher income
will increase our chances at being happy. What else do you need? Whatever you need
in general tells you something about what you want at work as well. You are not
a different person at work than at home. You have the same needs and values. If
you like meeting people or reading, then you will probably like meeting people or
reading as part of your work.
MAKE A LIST OF CAREER SELECTION CRITERIA
The key objective of gathering information about yourself is
to make a list of your Career Selection Criteria. Your Career Selection Criteria
are the result of all of your thinking about what you realistically want in a career.
Each criteria might represent one aspect of something that can make a difference
in your overall happiness or productivity. Examples of Career Selection Criteria
which might be important to you include "income," "variety," "vacation," "amount
of education required," "amount of contact with other people,""amount of freedom,"
"opportunities for advancement," "difficulty in getting into graduate school," etc.
Your list of Career Selection Criteria is a result of exploring
your interests, your skills and abilities, and all your other values and needs.
Thus they summarize everything that is important to you in making a career decision.
They are the dimensions by which you weigh the pluses and minuses of any particular
career or job that you might be considering. You will be able to use these selection
criteria more systematically in step 4 below. You can also use your criteria list
to think of questions when reading about occupations or interviewing people
in the actual occupations. This will make the career information you get more specific
to your own unique interests and needs. Making a good selection criteria list and
interviewing people in the careers are about the two most important things you can
do to make a good career decision. TRY DOING THE FOLLOWING.
1) MAKE AN INITIAL LIST. Take out a piece of paper and
first give yourself 5 minutes or less to write down everything that you can think
of that is important to you in a career.
2) EXPLORE THE POSSIBLE SELECTION CRITERIA BELOW. When
you have completed that initial list, then explore the following questions in order
to help you think of additional criteria which may be important to you. Try thinking
about or writing answers to each of the following questions. But remember to add
each important item to your Career Selection Criteria list. Explore each of the
following sections:
1.ACTIVITIES &
PRODUCTS ON THE JOB
2.WORKING
WITH OTHERS
3.ENTRY &
ADVANCEMENT REQUIREMENTS
4.CAREER-RELATED
SKILLS
5.EDUCATION,
EXPERIENCE, & OTHER REQUIREMENTS
6.EXTRINSIC
BENEFITS OF THE CAREER
7.WORK CONDITIONS
8.TRAVEL,
MOBILITY, & GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION
9.TYPE OF ORGANIZATION
10.YOUR FUTURE
11.EFFECTS ON YOUR LIFE OUTSIDE OF WORK
Return to INDEX
1.ACTIVITIES
AND PRODUCTS ON THE JOB
* What Are Your Interests? List your main interests and
activities whether or not they seem to relate to jobs.
* How Do You Want To Spend Your Time On Your Job? What
do you like doing? Imagine what some typical days might be like. Examples of types
of job activities you may want to seek or avoid:
* THING-ORIENTED ACTIVITIES * CREATIVE & IDEAL-ORIENTED
- Machine or manual activities? Creative writing?
- Athletic activities? Art?
- Engineering or other design?
* DATA-ORIENTED ACTIVITIES Program development?
- Detailed data processing? Scientific or knowledge discovery?
- Numerical or accounting? Learning & education?
- Clerical work? Designing computer programs?
* MANAGING OTHERS * SALES & MARKETING
- Organizing, planning? Persuading others?
- Supervising? Self-direction?
- Conflict resolution? Creative interpersonal ideas?
- Motivating others? Conversing with many others?
Return to INDEX
* HELPING, TEACHING, COUNSELING ACTIVITIES
- Speaking to groups?
- Counseling, advising, consulting?
- Instructing, teaching?
- Learning, reading?
* How Much Change And Variety Do You Like? Do you like
doing a lot of different things each day or would you like to work on one big project
until it is completed? Would you like to change jobs or projects frequently or not?
* How Mentally Challenging or Difficult Do You Want Your Work
To Be?
* What Do You Want To Contribute To Others? Do you like
to have others directly express appreciation for what you do? How important is it
to you that you are making a certain kind of contribution to society?
* What Products or Services Do You Have An Interest In?
Which type of product do you have more interest in? airplanes, cars, electronics,
fashion merchandise, art products, media, office products, computers, home furnishings,
houses, buildings, highways, plants, animals, food, entertainment, manufacturing
equipment, paper products, appliances, military-related, or what?
Or perhaps you would rather work in an organization that produces
a service such as education, counseling, religious activities, personal care, health
care, repair, consulting, accounting, food service, entertainment, artistic services,
sports training, personnel services, sales, marketing, research, writing or media
production, or one of many others.
Think about what natural interests you have and the type of organization
you might want to work for. Perhaps you could begin working or that type of organization
before graduation to get an early start and make your part-time work more interesting
and informative. It may help you get a good job after graduation.
Return to INDEX
2.WORKING
WITH OTHERS--WHAT DO YOU WANT?
Which Are Most Important To You On The Job?
- Think about how you feel about each of these different types
of relationships on the job. How much do you want to do
of each? How important is each?
- Managing Others? Being Managed Well?
- Freedom To Do What You Want? Working Alone?
- Helping Or Teaching Others? Being Part Of A Team
- Receiving Support From Others? Having Friends At Work?
- Persuading Or Selling To Others?
* Type and Amount of Supervision You Receive? Pay special
attention to the questions above concerning the type and amount of supervision you
receive. For example, if you like a lot of freedom to work without someone constantly
telling you what to do, and you don't get that freedom, it could lead to a lot of
unhappiness on your part. What type of supervision setting do you want?
3.ENTRY
AND ADVANCEMENT REQUIREMENTS
Educational and Training Requirements. Which are needed? Which
do you want?:
- College Degrees?
- Grade Average Expectations?
- Risk of Not Being Admitted To Graduate School?
- Special Licenses Or Credentials Required By The State Or
Profession?
- Supervised Experience Required?
- Experience Required?
- Portfolios, Publications, Or Other Products Required To
Get Jobs?
Return to INDEX
4.LIST YOUR
CAREER-RELATED SKILLS
* What Are Your Skills and Abilities? How do they compare to
the requirements for getting the degrees or other credentials or for getting the
first job in the field? In general how are your abilities and skills in the following
areas?
- Job-Related Technical Knowledge And Skills (The direct
knowledge and skills required to do the specialized tasks of the job.Examples:
For an engineer, math and science; for an executive, management skills.)
- General Thinking And Learning Skills (Such as problem-solving
skills, logical thinking, creative thinking skills, and study skills)
- Self-Management and Self-Motivation Skills (Such
time-management, goal-setting, positive philosophy, stress management, self-direction.)
- Interpersonal Skills (Such as meeting people, assertiveness,
teaching, leadership, persuading others, intimacy skills.)
5.EDUCATION, EXPERIENCE, AND OTHER REQUIREMENTS
- What Is the Cost of Getting Into That Career? How
does that compare with your expected inner resources such as motivation and
your external resources--such as money?
- How Competitive Is That Field?
- How Much Continued Education Or Professional Development
Is Expected? Do you want a job that requires continual learning? How important
is that?
Return to INDEX
6.THE
EXTRINSIC BENEFITS OF THE CAREER
- How Much Income Do You Expect? What is the minimum
you will accept to do what you really want? How important is it to you that
you make a lot of money? What are the long term financial prospects of that
occupation?
- How Much Vacation Do You Expect? How important is
this to you?
- How Much Job Security Do You Expect? How important
is this to you?
- What Kind of Retirement Plan and Benefits Do Your Expect?
7.WORK CONDITIONS
- What Kind of Work Hours Or Freedom of Scheduling Do You
Want? How important is that to you?
- What Kind of Physical Environment Do You Want To Work
In? Consider some of the following factors:
- Indoors vs. Outdoors? Privacy?
- Beauty of Environment? Pollution?
- Noise or distractions? Cleanliness?
- Office Setting? Health or Safety Risks?
* What Kind of Psychological Environment Do You Want To Work
In? Consider some of the following factors:
- Lots of pressure and deadlines?
- High uncertainty about what is expected?
- Competitive atmosphere?
- Job Insecurity?
- Paid By What You Produce vs. Regular Salary?
- Potential for Advancement?
Return to INDEX
8.TRAVEL, MOBILITY, AND GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION
- Where Do You Want To Work? How important is where
you live to you? How do you feel about working for an organization that may
want you to move around the country?
- How Do You Feel About Traveling As Part Of Your Work?
Remember that there is a great variety in where and how often employees travel.
9.TYPE OF ORGANIZATION
- Do you have any preferences about the type of organization
you work for? For example do you care if it is private or public? Do you
want to work in education or the military? Do you want to work for a large or
small organization?
10.YOUR FUTURE
Often college students only think about how well they will like
their first or "entry-level" job in their chosen occupation. They often don't even
consider their future beyond their first job. For example many jobs are "dead-end"
jobs with little opportunity for advancement. Others may offer many opportunities
for advancement into higher level positions within the occupation or may allow for
easier switching to new occupations. Some jobs may be challenging at first, but
become very routine after the first few years. Other jobs allow for continued change
and professional development. If you are the type of person that likes learning
or gets bored easily, this could be a major consideration. Following are some issues
to consider.
- Opportunities For Advancement?
- Opportunities For Professional Growth And Continued Stimulation--Avoiding
Boredom?
- What If You Don't Want To Do This The Rest Of Your Life?
-- Will Your Degree Help You Get Into other Careers Too?
- Opportunities for Advancement In Income?
Return to INDEX
11.EFFECTS OF YOUR CAREER ON YOUR LIFE OUTSIDE OF WORK
Careers can have effects of the rest of your life outside of
the work time and outside of the work environment. If you have to work odd hours,
move a lot, do a lot of social entertainment, live in a certain area, or come home
exhausted, your job can have major impacts on your personal or family life. Following
are a sample of issues to explore.
- Geographic Location?
- Effects On Your Family Life?
- Effects On Your Social Life?
- Effects On Your Recreation and Hobbies?
OTHER QUESTIONS TO EXPLORE
There are many other possible issues to explore which might be
important to add to your list of Career Selection Criteria.
- What school subjects do you enjoy the most?
Does this give you a clue to what you want to think about or learn about in
your daily work?
- What jobs or work experiences have you had?
What have you liked and disliked most about school or these work experiences?
- What else in your life do you enjoy doing?
How do you spend your time? Many persons turn hobbies into full-time jobs.
Return to INDEX
Keep your career selection criteria as you explore
careers--
Use them to write interview questions and make decisions
OTHER SELF-EXPLORATION ACTIVITIES--such as occupational interest
tests
* Consider occupational interest tests and other tests
at your Counseling Center or Career Development Center. You may also try other self-exploration
ideas suggested by your counselor.
* Consider computer career-search programs. Consider taking
"SIGI," a computer-assisted assessment or other programs that might be available
at your college.
Return to INDEX
STEP 3: CAREER EXPLORATION--
Gather information about the world of work
GENERATE ALTERNATIVE CAREER OPTIONS
Begin this step by "brainstorming" and listing all the occupations
or careers which you might in your wildest dreams be interested in. This is because
you don't want to initially exclude possibilities. Once you have a basic idea of
what some of your more important Career Selection Criteria are and have an initial
list of possible occupations to explore, then you are ready to more systematically
begin exploring the world of work. Some suggestions follow: Use your Career Selection
Criteria to help guide you in making a list of questions you want to use to evaluate
each occupation, or just use your Career Selection Criteria "as is."
Return to INDEX
USE WRITTEN INFORMATION TO GET A GENERAL OVERVIEW
* Go to your Career Information Center. Once you are there you
may want to start with one of these prime reference sources.
Occupational Outlook Handbook (the "BIBLE" of career
information)--This is the best , most up-to-date single
career information resource. Find careers your interested in and read about them.
As you read reflect, add new career selection criteria. Also: Take notes.
===> To view the OCC go to it's internet address at:
Dictionary of Occupational Titles--Use
this reference to find thousands of job titles. If you are looking for a job that
is different or combines more than one interest, try this resource.
United States Government Manual (lists U.S. government
jobs)--Use this if you have any interest in Federal government-related
jobs. Take a look, there are many interesting federal jobs that most students never
even think about.
State, County, and City Government Job Books. If
you have an interest in working for other levels of government, go to state, county,
and city government personnel offices or a large library (such as your college)
and ask to see the large books that list all types of job classifications. You'll
be amazed at all the types of jobs available that few college students ever even
know exist.
Company Literature. Many other organizations also
produce job-information literature. See what is available at your career information
center and library. Also, write organizations you might have an interest in. Address
their personnel offices.
Return to INDEX
* Make a Career Information file and put all of your self-assessment
information in it as well as notes you take as you read the career information literature
and interview persons.
* Look at a WIDE VARIETY OF OCCUPATIONS--even some you
may think you have little interest in. This may help you clarify additional Career
Selection Criteria and think of new career alternatives you formerly had not considered.
Be sure and include any occupations for which you received high scores on your interest
tests.
WHERE THE JOBS ARE
Would you like to know which occupations are going to have many
openings compared to the number of job seekers in the future? You will find that
there are many books, newspaper articles, TV news reports, employees, friends, relatives,
and nearly everyone else who is willing to predict where the jobs will be in the
future. Most of these sources will state their predictions with a high degree of
certainty. What has been the accuracy of these types of predictions in the past?
The answer is "very poor to good." The reason the predictions tend to be so bad
so often is that world events often have dramatic impacts upon jobs, and world events
are so unpredictable.
Who is selected governor or president, states of war, new government
programs, and sudden shifts in college major preferences by large numbers of students
are all examples of almost unpredictable major events that greatly effect worker
supply and demand. So take what you hear with a great deal of skepticism and go
more with what you want. How would you feel if you go into a career you don't care
much for because people say"there are lots of jobs," then later it turns out that
there are not many jobs after all?
Return to INDEX
INTERVIEW PEOPLE IN THE OCCUPATION
This is probably the most important thing that you can do to
get information about careers. Most of the students I talk to have difficulty thinking
of people in a career they are interested in to interview. Following are some suggestions
which have worked for many other students.
Step 1: Finding Persons in the Occupation to Interview.
1. Think of everyone who you have contact with including faculty,
friends, relatives, friends of relatives, or just "call cold" persons in various
organizations.
2. Find professors in related major departments and interview
them. They are being paid to help students and have office hours available that
you can utilize.
3. Ask everyone you know (including professors) if they or anyone
they know either
(1) works in the profession or
(2) knows anyone who works in the profession. For example
if they work in a large organization they may be able to get you an interview with
someone else in that organization.
(3) If the above ideas aren't adequate, call organizations where
people in the occupation might work and ask to speak to someone who works in that
profession. Use the phone book yellow pages or go to the library or Career Development
Center to get names and phone numbers of such organizations.
==> TIP: Find people to interview who are happy and successful
in their job.
Return to INDEX
Step 2: Getting the Interview
Many students are reluctant to contact people because they are
concerned that they may be bothering the busy professional or taking too much of
their time. First of all it is important for them to realize that if the professional
does not have time for them, then they will almost certainly tell them. However,
most professionals truly enjoy helping students. How would you feel if 10 years
from now if a college student came to you? The feedback that I get from students
who have tried this is that almost all people they approach are very cooperative
and give them tremendously valuable information.
When you find a person to interview or call an organization,
try saying something like, "I'm a college student who is trying to make a decision
about going into this occupation and it would be very helpful to me if I could interview
{this person} for a few minutes to ask them a few questions about this type of career."
If you reach a secretary, be persistent about getting the actual person in the occupation
to make the decision about whether to interview you or not.
Step 3: Conducting the Interview
If possible meet the person in their place of work. Come with
a list of questions based upon your list of career selection criteria and use the
list openly during the interview.
What to ask the interviewee
- His/her title and job description
- Employer, products or services, division/unit,
- What this person's job and unit contributes to the company
as a whole
- Entry level requirements: education & training, credentials,
experience, personal resources and skills
- Opportunities and requirements for advancement
- Salaries: low, average, high of beginning and advanced employees
- Supply and demand for persons in that field
- His/her activities: exactly what he/she and others do in
a typical day or week
- What are differences in what he/she does from what others
in the same occupation do?
- What other types of work does this type of job or occupation
prepare a person to do in the future if one wants to advance or change?
- What does this person like and dislike about the occupation?
- What are common likes and dislikes of people in this occupation?
Return to INDEX
What didn't you ask that you should have? Ask what else
you should know about this occupation that you have not asked so far. What would
this person have wanted to find out that they didn't know before getting into field?
Use your CAREER SELECTION CRITERIA to make additional questions.
These are probably your most important questions!
ADDITIONAL TIPS
- Remember to evaluate what you hear by your own Career Selection
Criteria. Your interests and values may be quite different from those of the
person you are interviewing.
- During the interview tell the person about yourself so that
he/she may give information which may be more relevant to you.
- During the interview, ask for the names and phone numbers
of persons your
interviewee knows, whom you can later call to interview.
Later call them and tell them you were referred by Mr. so and so.
- Check for opportunities for volunteer or paid work experience.
- Don't be turned off the whole profession by one unhappy
or negative interviewee. If you get too much negative information, try at least
one other person who is happier in their work.
- When finished thank the interviewee and later write a thank
you letter.
Return to INDEX
STEP 4: MAKE A DECISION--
Reduce the number of alternatives
As you gather information about yourself and the world of work,
you will naturally begin to eliminate some career options and add others. People
often think that if they have not yet found their "ideal career," then there is
something wrong. Actually, having a variety of career options may not only
be "ok," but is often very desirable. Even if you decide upon "one" occupation,
such as an engineer, it is wise to "keep your options open" for the future. Even
if you become an engineer, later you may want to have options for changing jobs
and perhaps selling, managing, teaching, or owning your own business. A person with
more developed options is more prepared for the future. Nevertheless, it is important
to make some decisions which narrow your alternatives.
For example, you need to decide upon a major, perhaps a minor,
and you need to decide what other courses you will take to prepare for your future.
Once you are ready to make that decision, you will need a way of comparing each
of your important career alternatives on each of your important Career Selection
Criteria.
Following is a suggested method for doing that. This particular
decision-making model is based upon one by Friel and Carkhuff and follows the general
guidelines of a considerable amount of research on how people can make more effective
decisions. It can also be used for any other type of decision--from buying a new
car to choosing a mate.
EXAMPLE OF USING THE DECISION-MAKING MODEL
The decision-making model will be illustrated in a way which
you can use an analogy for making your own career decision. In this example, Henry
is trying to decide whether to major in psychology or in computer science. Thus
he has narrowed his alternatives to the following two:
1) majoring in psychology with a career goal of either going
into high school counseling or teaching or 2) majoring in computer science with
a possible goal of working as a computer programmer. These are represented along
the top axis of the following matrix.
Return to INDEX
(CAREER)
SELECTION CRITERIA |
WEIGHTS
|
IDEAL
|
PSYCHOLOGY
|
COMPUTER SCIENCE
|
Income
|
9
|
+5 (45)
|
+2 (18)
|
+4 (36)
|
Vacation
|
7
|
+5 (35 )
|
+5 (35)
|
+2 ( 14)
|
Helping Others
|
10
|
+5 ( 50)
|
+4 ( 40)
|
+4 ( 40)
|
Future job options
|
8
|
+5 ( 50)
|
+3 ( 24)
|
+4 (32)
|
Supply/demand
|
6
|
+5 ( 30)
|
medium( -6)
|
0 ( 0)
|
Working hours
|
3
|
+5 ( 15)
|
+4 ( 12)
|
+3 ( 9)
|
Opportunity to teach others
|
9
|
+5 ( 45)
|
+5 ( 45)
|
+4 (36)
|
Helping personal interactions
|
10
|
+5 ( 50)
|
+5 ( 50)
|
+1 ( 10)
|
Security/retirement plans
|
5
|
+5 ( 25)
|
+4 ( 20)
|
+3 ( 15)
|
Enjoyment socialize with peers
|
5
|
+5 ( 25)
|
+4 ( 20)
|
+4 ( 20)
|
Opportunity to make own decisions
|
9
|
+5 ( 45)
|
+4 ( 36)
|
+3 ( 27)
|
Freedom for personal life as want
|
8
|
+5 ( 40)
|
+5 ( 40)
|
+5 ( 40)
|
Opports for continued learning
|
6
|
+5 ( 30)
|
+4 ( 24)
|
+4 ( 24)
|
Physical work environment
|
2
|
+5 ( 10)
|
+3 ( 6)
|
+2 ( 4)
|
Psychological environ & stress
|
3
|
+5 ( 15)
|
0 ( 0)
|
medium( -3)
|
Variety of work
|
5
|
+5 ( 25)
|
+2 ( 10)
|
+3 ( 15)
|
Opportunities for creativity |
7 |
+5 ( 35) |
+3 ( 21) |
+4 ( 28) |
TOTAL POINTS (add "happiness
points" in parentheses)
|
|
570=possible
|
( 347)
|
( 405)**
|
**
is the WINNER-it has the most points of the two alternatives
Return to INDEX
STEPS TO THE DECISION-MAKING MODEL (Use example above)STEP 1-- LIST YOUR CAREER ALTERNATIVES. This is your refined
list of alternatives of which majors or occupations you are trying to decide between.
Remember, that you can list as many as you want. You can list unusual combinations
of simpler alternatives. For Henry those narrowed alternatives were psychology and
computer science.
STEP 2--CAREER SELECTION CRITERIA. Review your Career
Selection Criteria list and write all the important career selection criteria in
the far left column. Note that repeating the same idea or leaving out an important
idea can affect the decision outcome.
STEP 3-- CRITERIA WEIGHTS. Evaluate the relative importance
to you of each of your Career Selection Criteria on a scale of 1 to 10 (10 being
the most important). Write your answer in the column next to the selection criteria.
STEP 4--ALTERNATIVE EVALUATION SCALE. Each alternative
is to be evaluated from the point of view of each selection criterion. You need
to think about what this means for each selection criterion. For example Henry determined
that for the selection criteria of income, a "minimally acceptable" income
would be $25,000 starting with prospects of making up to $50,000 eventually. An
outstanding salary would be starting at about $40,000 with prospects of making up
to $100,000.
+5 = Maximum evaluation--outstanding (example: income
begins at $40,000 goes to $100,000
+4, +3, +2, +1 = intermediate values
0 = Minimally acceptable value. (Example: income = begins
at $20,000 goes to $45,000)
medium, -2, -3, -4 = intermediate values
-5 = Minimum evaluation--worst possible (Example: income
begins at less than $10,000)
Return to INDEX
STEP 5--EVALUATE EACH ALTERNATIVE BY EACH SELECTION CRITERION.
Use the evaluation scale from step 3 to evaluate each alternative from the point
of view of each Career Selection Criterion. Give it rating from -5 to +5. In the
example above, both alternatives were evaluated on the criterion of "income": Henry
gave the psychology income an evaluation of "+2" and computer science income an
evaluation of " +4."
STEP 6--MULTIPLY THE CRITERIA WEIGHTS TIMES THE EVALUATIONS.
In the example above for the selection criterion of "income," Henry multiplied
the criterion weight of "9" times the evaluation of " +2" for "PSYCH" to get a result
of "18." That is its SCORE OR POINTS for psychology on the criterion of income.
Put it inside of the parentheses. This score of 18 is an overall prediction much
Henry's income in psychology will contribute to his overall happiness. Since he
had a score of 36 in computer science, he his predicting that he will be much happier
with his income in that field.
STEP 7--FIND THE OVERALL SUM OF THE SCORES FOR EACH ALTERNATIVE.
Add together the numbers inside the parentheses for each alternative. In the example
above, the overall sum for the "PSYCH" alternative is "405."
STEP 8--COMPARE THE ALTERNATIVES WITH EACH OTHER AND
WITH THE "IDEAL." The "ideal" is the maximum possible number of points. Once
you have determined all the totals and compared them to each other, try to figure
out why one alternative came out ahead of another--where it got its points. Play
with the points until you think the points match your true feelings and values.
==> The alternative with the most points
is the one you are predictingwill make you the happiest person overall. Return to INDEX
WHAT IF YOU ARE NOT READY TO CHOOSE ONE ALTERNATIVE MAJOR
OR CAREER NOW?
Many students just have not done enough exploration to make a
final decision about their major. Following is a list of several strategies which
we recommend if you are undecided.
* Inquire about the course requirements of the majors you are
strongly considering. Start with the major which has the MOST REQUIREMENTS or the
major which requires that you take SPECIFIC GENERAL EDUCATION COURSES (such as chemistry,
biology, physics, calculus, or economics).
* Start taking courses which are good introductions or overviews
of that major. * You may also TAKE GENERAL EDUCATION COURSES for which you have
the PROPER BACKGROUND and which DO NOT CONFLICT WITH MAJOR REQUIREMENTS for those
same general education requirements. For example, suppose you are considering a
major in business and a major in health science. If the business major requires
that you take an economics course and it also meets the social science general education
requirement, you might wait to fill that general education requirement if you are
not really very interested in economics. Take it after you make your decision about
your major.
* You may begin PREPARING FOR TWO OR MORE MAJORS AT ONCE. If
you can't choose between two majors, you can begin taking courses in both. This
delays your decision until you have done more exploration. Later you may decide
to major in one and minor in the other. In any case, having more than one area of
concentration can look good on a resume later.
* If you decide to prepare for more than one major at once, then
take the most courses
1) in the major WITH THE MOST COURSE REQUIREMENTS and/or
2) in the major YOU CURRENTLY FAVOR THE MOST.
* If you CAN'T NARROW YOUR ALTERNATIVE MAJORS TO TWO OR THREE
and have completed your general education requirements, then
1) redouble your efforts at making a decision--GET HELP NOW,
2) continue taking courses in the most likely majors,
3) try making a TENTATIVE DECISION. A tentative decision means
that you pick the most likely alternative and pursue it until you change your mind.
One important rule in making that tentative decision is:
* If you are STILL UNDECIDED, pick a major that is LESS SPECIALIZED,
is MORE FLEXIBLE, and is ACCEPTED in more entry-level jobs (or graduate schools)
in the general type of organizational setting in which you might be most comfortable
(such as education, technical, medical, business, etc.).
Return to INDEX
WHAT IF YOU NEVER KNOW WHAT YOU REALLY WANT TO DO?
Does this sound so awful to you? Actually, most jobs are not
really people's ideas of the "ideal job." Do jobs like "clerk," "machinist," "garbage
collector," "management assistant" sound like "ideal jobs." Probably not. Most people
do not work in jobs that they decided would be ideal for them when they were 22.
Most people end up in the jobs they are in because it was the best thing available
at the time for someone with their education, experience, interests, and background.
They may not be overjoyed about their work, but they find it interesting and it
meets many of their selection criteria--such a providing an income. Think about
the your parents and other people you have known who have had careers for 10, 20,
or more years.
Many people work to make money so they can enjoy the rest of
their life. They feel a sense of accomplishment for what the contribute to the benefit
of society. People enjoy the people they work with, the setting, and many other
aspects of the job other than the "content" of what they do. Therefore, it you can't
find your "ideal career," then just do the best you can using your Career Selection
Criteria list and try to pick a major that is useful for many of your general areas
of interest. However, to the extent that you keep actively using the ideas presented
in this paper, then you are increasing the chances that you will be one of those
fortunate few who do accurately predict what career they will be happiest in,
and actually end up happy and successful in that very career.
Return to INDEX
STEP 5: PLANNING: Make a career preparation plan
Once you have made some sort of tentative decision about what
major(s) and career(s) you are going to pursue, then you are ready to begin actually
planning how to prepare for that major(s) or career(s).
* To help with process I suggest that you complete the "Career
and Life Preparation Plan" form or COMPLETE EACH SECTION BELOW IN WRITING ON YOUR
OWN PAPER.
1) ACADEMIC MAJOR DEVELOPMENT PLAN
- Degree objective(s) and Expected Date(s)
- Major Course Requirements (list courses)
- Grade Point Average Objective
- Certification or Licensure Objective(s)--if any
2) SUPPLEMENTARY ACADEMIC AREA DEVELOPMENT PLAN
- Types of Skills and Knowledge Desired
- Areas of Course Concentration To Supplement Major Certification?
3) LIFE SKILLS DEVELOPMENT PLAN--Development of personal
attributes which you need to meet your goals for maximum success in your career
and personal life.
- Thinking, Learning, and Problem-Solving Skills (Learned
skills in math, logic, creative thinking, study skills, concentration, etc.)
- Self-Motivation and Self-Management Skills (Learned
skills in time-management, goal-setting, achievement motivation, self-discipline,
stress & emotional coping skills, positive philosophy of life, clear career
goals, etc.)
- Interpersonal Skills (Learned skills in meeting people,
assertiveness, conflict resolution, intimacy, persuasiveness, and leadership.)
- Life skills development goals--Life Skills o Focus
On (from the above list or own ideas.
ACTIVITIES--What I Intend To Do To Attain Those Goals Academic
Courses To Complete Individual Help Activities (Example "Make appointment at counseling
Center to get help with assertiveness")
- Self-Help Activities (Example Read self-help books)
- Workshops (Example "Take time-management workshop")
- Organizations (Example "Get active in department association.")
Return to INDEX
4) WORK EXPERIENCE PLAN--For a more planned approach to
getting work experience relevant to your career and getting course credit for your
work experience, see your department advisor and/or a counselor in the Cooperative
Education program in the Career Development Center, SSA-250.)
- Type of Work Experience Desired and Dates
- Amount of Income Needed/Desired? Willing to do Volunteer
Work?
- Course Credit Desired?
- Supervised Hours For Licensure or Special Credentials Desired?
5) OTHER GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS AND DATES OF EXPECTED COMPLETION
- If you are certain which catalog you must follow for graduation
requirements, consult with that catalog to develop a checklist of your graduation
requirements. The "Schedule of Classes" current when you entered provides an
even more convenient checklist of graduation requirements. SAVE IT UNTIL YOU
GRADUATE.
- * If you are unsure about your graduation requirements in
your major, consult with a department advisor and get any statements of requirements
IN WRITING.
- * If you are unsure about any other graduation requirements,
consult with an advisor at your Academic Advising Center.
Return to INDEX
* Add your intended ACTIONS and EXPECTED DATES OF COMPLETION
OF THOSE GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS to your preparation plan HERE. Remember that there
are a significant number of requirements besides course requirements. Following
is a general list for California State University, Long Beach.
1) Academic Major Requirements
2) General Education Requirements
3) Upper Division Unit Requirements (40)
4) TOTAL UNIT Requirements (124medium36 depends on major)
5) Grade Point Average Requirements (there are at least FIVE
separate GPA requirements)
6) Writing Skills Requirements--EPT or alternative AND WPE or
alternative.
7) Math Skills Requirements--ELM or alternative
8) Completion of University 100
9) Residency requirements
10) Can't count too many units in PE or Extended Education.
11) Filing Graduation Check for Final University Approval
* Be sure that you understand and plan for each of these requirements
Return to INDEX
6) FEEDBACK FROM OTHERS
Once you have completed this "Career and Life Preparation Plan,"
then consult knowledgeable others for feedback on your plan. Consult with department
advisors, Academic Advising Center advisors, persons employed in your fields of
interest, or others whose opinion you value. Let them look over you plan and discuss
it with you. Remember though that you are the one who should make the final decision--IT
IS YOUR LIFE YOU ARE PREPARING FOR.
* What you do now can make a great deal of difference in how
happy and successful you are in the future!
Return to INDEX
STEPS 6 & 7: ACTION AND GATHERING FEEDBACK:
Try out your choicesOnce you have completed
your initial planning, it is time to begin testing your plan and taking action to
complete your plans. Keep your "Career and Life Preparation Plan" available throughout
your college career and keep updating it as you change your plans. Remember, that
persons who do more planning and have more clear goals tend to be more successful
in their careers.
Be OPEN TO FEEDBACK from OTHERS and from YOUR OWN FEELINGS. If
you keep getting strong nagging feelings that a certain career or major may not
be right for you, do not ignore those feelings. Instead check them out. Think about
them to clearly identify their source, get more information about the career, and
possibly explore new alternatives. In general don't stay with a major just because
you started it or just because it is important to someone else.
Return to INDEX
&
SUMMARY:The most important parts of making a career decision
are:
(1) Making a complete and accurate
list of your career SELECTION CRITERIA, (2) Exploring career information--especially INTERVIEWING
PEOPLE, (3) Making the decision--use
the DECISION-MAKING MODEL,and (4) Acting on your decision and assessing the results.Return to INDEX
IF THIS SELF-HELP MANUAL IS NOT ENOUGH to help you through
the career decision-making process--Get help from one of the resources mentioned
earlier: * COUNSELING CENTER * CAREER DEVELOPMENT CENTER * ACADEMIC ADVISING CENTER * YOUR ACADEMIC MAJOR ADVISOR--Contact your department office.
The career decision you make now,
may be one of the most important decisions of your
life.It can have a great
effect on what you do 40 hours/week
for many years and can affect your income and your personal
life.Isn't it important
enough to spend a few hours
taking the steps in this little manual?
Good Luck, give me feedback at
tstevens@csulb.edu.
Return to INDEX/a>
|