Assignment #10

Identify the philosphical positions vis a vis freewill and determinism of the two people in the dialogue below, explaining

what each position holds and what about the person's statements suggest that position:

Watsup : By Jove, Sholmes , I've got it! There is no murder because, because murder implies moral culpability, i.e., freewill. However, Peacock was determined by physical necessity in the form of pheromones and hormones to kill his wife in order to lounge comfortably on a south seas island with Ms. Scarlett !

Sholmes : Don't be mislead by he obvious Watsup ! It's true that a combination of motive and opportunity in the form of the lovely Ms. Scarlett caused Mr. Peacock to kill his wife with the with the garlic press in the solarium as surely as gravity causes the moon to rotate around the Earth. However, Peacock's actions arose from primarily because he was configured to act in morally unacceptable ways--making his action MURDER!

Assignment #10

Identify the philosphical positions vis a vis freewill and determinism of the two people in the dialogue below, explaining

what each position holds and what about the person's statements suggest that position:

Watsup : By Jove, Sholmes , I've got it! There is no murder because, because murder implies moral culpability, i.e., freewill. However, Peacock was determined by physical necessity in the form of pheromones and hormones to kill his wife in order to lounge comfortably on a south seas island with Ms. Scarlett !

Sholmes : Don't be mislead by he obvious Watsup ! It's true that a combination of motive and opportunity in the form of the lovely Ms. Scarlett caused Mr. Peacock to kill his wife with the with the garlic press in the solarium as surely as gravity causes the moon to rotate around the Earth. However, Peacock's actions arose from primarily because he was configured to act in morally unacceptable ways--making his action MURDER!

Assignment #10

Identify the philosphical positions vis a vis freewill and determinism of the two people in the dialogue below, explaining

what each position holds and what about the person's statements suggest that position:

Watsup : By Jove, Sholmes , I've got it! There is no murder because, because murder implies moral culpability, i.e., freewill. However, Peacock was determined by physical necessity in the form of pheromones and hormones to kill his wife in order to lounge comfortably on a south seas island with Ms. Scarlett !

Sholmes : Don't be mislead by he obvious Watsup ! It's true that a combination of motive and opportunity in the form of the lovely Ms. Scarlett caused Mr. Peacock to kill his wife with the with the garlic press in the solarium as surely as gravity causes the moon to rotate around the Earth. However, Peacock's actions arose from primarily because he was configured to act in morally unacceptable ways--making his action MURDER!