Rubric for Ethics: an understanding of one's professional and ethical responsibilities, including the ability to analyze the ethical implications of one's professional work.

Advanced Proficient
	Understands general ethical principles including important 
        distinctions that affect our ethical judgments.  Able to identify 
        stakeholders, risks, problems, benefits, and possible actions. 
        Provides  detailed analyses referring to professional codes of 
        ethics.

Proficient
	Understands general ethical principles including most important 
        distinctions that affect our ethical judgments. Mostly able to 
        identify stakeholders, risks, problems, benefits, and possible 
        actions. Provides analyses referring to professional codes of 
        ethics.

Partially Proficient
	Knows some ethical principles and some important distinctions that 
        affect our ethical judgments. Incompletely identifies stakeholders, 
        risks, problems, benefits, and possible actions. Analyses weakly 
        supported.

Not Proficient
	Lacks understanding of general ethical principles including most 
        important distinctions that affect our ethical judgments.  Rarely 
        able to identify stakeholders, risks, problems, benefits, and 
        possible actions. Mostly unable to provides  detailed analyses 
        referring to professional codes of ethics.